1959-60

• Dark of the Moon (The)

• Death of a Salesman 

• Hamlet

• Auntie Mame 

• Say Darling 

• Tunnel of Love (The)

• Who Was That Lady

 

1960-61

• Cat On a Hot Tin Roof

• No Time For Sergeants 

• Rashomon 

• Bells Are Ringing

• Marriage-Go-Round 

• J.B. 

• Boy Friend  (The)

 

1961-62

• Beckett  

• Golden Fleecing 

• Romanoff and Juliet

• Pal Joey

• Seven Year Itch (The) 

• Visit (The) 

• Once Upon a Mattress 

 

1962-63

• Desk Set (The) 

• Andersonville Trial (The) 

• Peter Pan

• Big Knife (The)

• Send Me No Flowers 

• Summer and Smoke

• Babes in Armes

 

1963-64

• Come Blow Your Horn  

• Devil’s Advocate (The)

• Take Her She’s Mine 

• Gazebo (The)

• Critic’s Choice

• Richard III

• Flower Drum Song

 

1964-65

• Best Man (The)

• Little Mary Sunshine 

• Write Me a Murder

• Captain’s Paradise (The)

• Othello

• Under the Yum Yum Tree

• Three Penny Opera

 

1965-66

• Mary, Mary

• Fantasticks (The)

• Look Homeward Angel

• Oh Dad, Poor Dad... 

• George Washington Slept Here 

• Irma La Douce 

• Skin of Our Teeth 

 

1966-67

• Sunday in New York 

• Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf

• Taming of The Shrew (The)

• Two for the Seesaw 

• Shrike (The) 

• Funny Thing Happened...

• Royal Family  (The)

 

1967-68

• A Thousand Clowns

• Crucible (The) 

• Here’s Love 

• Bald Soprano (The) & The Chairs  

• Julius Caesar

• Waltz of the Toreadors 

• Man With a Load of Mischief 

 

1968-69

• Boys From Syracuse 

• Die Fledermaus

• Man Who Came to Dinner (The)

• Merchant of Venice 

• Sweet Charity

• Odd Couple (The)

• Rose Tattoo

• Royal Hunt of the Sun

 

1969-70

• Oliver!

• Women (The)

• MacBeth

• Impossible Years 

• Summertree

• Gigi

• Man For All Seasons (A)

• Don’t Drink the Water